Login   |   Join Now

UPDATED with Senate Vote: Environmental Lobby Wins Baby-Bottle Battle in State House

Fight Now Turns to Senate – Will it Ban BPA Sports-Water Bottles as Well?

 




UPDATE: OLYMPIA, Jan. 29, 12:00 P.M.--The state Senate passed its version of the BPA-ban bill by a vote of 36-9. House and Senate now face a fight over whether to extend the ban to cover sports-water bottles.
 

By Erik Smith

Staff writer/ Washington State Wire

 

OLYMPIA, Jan. 26.—Just in time for a big state environmental lobbying day today, the Washington state House Monday passed a bill that bans the use of bisphenol A (BPA) plastics in baby products and sports water bottles.

            It was the second time around for the measure, which was introduced and passed last year by the state House as well, only to die in the Senate. And the only major change was the vote – this time House Bill 1180 passed by a near-unanimous score of 95 to 1.

            Last year the bill passed the state House by a vote of 76-21.

The measure is one of the top priorities for the state environmental lobby this year. Environmentalists have mounted a national crusade against the compound, which for more than 50 years has been used to make clean shatterproof plastic and liners for metal cans and jar lids.

Environmentalists contend the compound can cause developmental problems as well as cancer and heart disease in adults. Although some studies have pointed to hazards, researchers have had difficulty reproducing the results – an essential element in proving a scientific case. Regulatory agencies around the world, relying on studies that have determined the plastic to be safe, have declined to take action.

            Two weeks ago the federal Food and Drug Administration, responding to the furor, urged caution in the use of BPA in products that might be used by infants and small children, but did not take further action.

            Meanwhile, environmentalists have turned to the political arena to obtain the restrictions that regulators are reluctant to provide. Last year legislatures in Minnesota and Connecticut passed measures banning BPA in baby products. Washington would become the third state to enact a ban – but only if it beats Oregon, California, Maryland, Illinois, and Vermont, where environmentalists also are pushing for restrictions.

            In Washington state, the House vote makes it appear that the battle has shifted from baby products to at least one product that is used by adults. A similar anti-BPA bill has been approved by a committee in the state Senate, but the key difference between the House and Senate measures is that Senate Bill 6248 does not ban the use of the plastic in sports water bottles. Lawmakers on the Senate Health and Long Term Care Committee argued that the Legislature should go no further than federal regulators, and noted that manufacturers of baby bottles and sippy cups already are removing BPA from their formulations because of consumer pressure. That meant the bill would have little effect other than that which is already occurring.

            Environmentalists, led by the Washington Toxics Coalition, said they would mount an effort in the Senate to include sports-water bottles in a Washington-state BPA ban. Clifford Traisman, lead lobbyist for the Environmental Priorities Coalition, said, “this is a huge win, and we hope the Senate moves to pass it just as swiftly."

            The vote in the state House Monday showed that even some of the state’s most conservative lawmakers now are willing to vote against the BPA. During the floor debate, some cited the FDA statement as evidence that harm has been discovered. Said Spokane Valley Republican Matt Shea, “We had expressed some concerns about the data. Well, now the data is in…I urge a ‘yes’ vote.”

            The lone dissenting vote against the measure was cast by Rep. Bruce Chandler, R-Granger.




EmaildividerPrintdividerComments (130)dividerBack to top






Comments On This Articlesubscribe to this comment thread Subscribe to this comment thread

WashingtonStateWire.com


Great site. Keep doing.  
WashingtonStateWire.com


I am so excited to see that our state government is jumping on the band wagon to take action on this long known issue with BPA in plastics. The supervisors looked at me cold when I mentioned BPA in plastic 5 years ago at Bright Horizons in the University Village of Seattle, like I was just a trouble maker. We heated up the plastic bottles all the time in bottle warmers. I am not an ignoramus in science. I have a college degree in science with a basic knowledge of chemistry and work in biotech research as well as laboratory pathology. Trying to raise more awareness in addressing the BPA issue with one of the mothers who was a medical doctor at Seattle Childrens, I got no where, no concern. Thank you for every effort to get rid of BPAs. 




Add Comment

Your Name:


Your Email Address: (Not displayed with comment.)




Comments:


Spotlight
House Approves $690 Million Package of Tax Hikes
House Approves $690 Million Package of Tax Hikes
By: Associated Press
After five hours of debate, Democrats in the state House passed a $690 million tax increase. Now the key decisions on the tax increases you'll be paying will be made by a legislative negotiating panel, behind closed doors.

-- Story inside
Oil Tax is Back – Green Lawmakers Making Big Push in Final Days of Session
Oil Tax is Back – Green Lawmakers Making Big Push in Final Days of Session
By: Erik Smith | Washington State Wire | March 9, 2010

A last-minute effort to raise taxes on oil and other hazardous substances is being mounted by enviromental groups and green-minded legislators. The new plan would more than double the tax, and devote money to water cleanup, not the general fund.

-- Story inside
Love Letter to Our Neighbors --Idaho is Open for Your Business
Love Letter to Our Neighbors --Idaho is Open for Your Business
By: C.L. "Butch" Otter, Governor of Idaho | Special to Washington State Wire | March 9, 2010

Idaho governor invites Washington businesses to beat high taxes by relocating in the Gem State.

-- Story inside

The Question No One Asked
By: Jim Boldt | Washington State Wire | March 5, 2010
The Washington State Senate took a baby step in the right direction yesterday when it showed the courage to at least discuss an income tax. For those in attendance, or virtually attending, we heard the same old crap. Yes, our state’s sales tax is regressive; yes, our constitution probably requires an amendment for a graduated income tax; and yes, unless we overhaul the whole revenue scheme, an inc...
Comments (0)Read more...
Oh Sweet Wheat!
By: Jim Boldt | Washington State Wire | March 2, 2010
As the House Democrats roll out their economically-counterintuitive tax increase in the middle of a the great recession, it could be praised by advocates as a simple little tax. There is nothing much complicated or new about it. The proposed substitute bill for HB 3191 raises a lot of money, and from what I read none of it is temporary!

So the first issue is that, if and when our state’s ec...
Comments (0)Read more...
Yellow, Webbed Feet, Quacks? Ducks and Redistribution of Wealth
By: Jim Boldt | Washington State Wire | Feb. 27
During the push of getting a budget out, the legislators need to go outside and walk around the lake. I did decades ago as a member of the budget committee. I did it to think about what an old-timer had told me. He was a very conservative Democratic old-timer from Eastern Washington. I was young and he was old and he suggested I see government for what it really is.

The entire state govern...
Comments (0)Read more...
Read more CapitolStuff  

Latest News
Moeller to Continue as FERC Commissioner
Moeller to Continue as FERC Commissioner
Local Boy Makes Good -- Was Former Staff Director for State Senate's Energy and Utility Committee
By: Seattle Post-Intelligencer
Susan Hutchison to Challenge Patty Murray?
Susan Hutchison to Challenge Patty Murray?
Former Television News Reader Built Name During King County Race
By: Seattle Post-Intelligencer
Lawmakers Pass Evergreen Point Bridge Bill
Lawmakers Pass Evergreen Point Bridge Bill
Allows Construction to Begin, Doesn't Address Local Snit Over Design
By: Seattle Post-Intelligencer
House Approves Transportation Budget
House Approves Transportation Budget
Measure Maintains Highway Funding -- No Startling Changes to Last Year's Plan
By: Associated Press
Lawmakers Endorse Pair of Bills Limiting Bail
Lawmakers Endorse Pair of Bills Limiting Bail
Voters Will Have Final Say
By: The Olympian
Senators Restore Funding for Seattle Elections Panel Funding
Believe City Needs Own Watchdog
By: Seattle Times
Legislature Sends BPA Bill to Governor's Desk
Legislature Sends BPA Bill to Governor's Desk
Would Ban BPA-Plastic Baby Bottles, Sippy Cups
By: Seattle Post-Intelligencer
Tax Debate Could Extend Session
House and Senate are Far Apart -- Point of No Return is Approaching
By: Seattle Times
Boeing Has No Competition in Tanker Contest
Boeing Has No Competition in Tanker Contest
Has Inside Track on $35 Billion Tanker Contract
By: McClatchy Newspapers
UW Pay Freeze is Upheld
UW Pay Freeze is Upheld
Court Says School Was Within Rights to Block Pay Raises Last Year
By: Seattle Times
Read more Latest News

"Boxers" by Brian Fairrington

By: Kaiser Health News
SNL's Take on Health Reform
SNL's Take on Health Reform
A Funny Saturday Night Live Video take on Obama-Care
By: SNL NBC
53% Remain Opposed to Health Care
The President still looks for votes, ignoring the public. 42% favor the plan while 53% are opposed. These figures include just 20% who Strongly Favor the plan and 41% who are Strongly Opposed.
By: RAMUSSEN Reports
57% Predict Health Care Plan Will Hurt The Economy
25% believe it will help the economy,and 78% believe it is likley to raise taxes on middle income families.
By: RAMUSSEN Reports
Obama and the L-Word
At the State of the Union Address the President said to have “stopped the revolving door between government and corporate lobbying.” More then 40 former lobbyists work for the administration. Pro-reform lobbyists outspent anti-reform lobbyists on advertising by a factor of 5 to 1.
Obama Attacks Insurers, Rallies Public To Press Congress To Approve Health Reform
Obama Attacks Insurers, Rallies Public To Press Congress To Approve Health Reform
President Obama launched a major health reform offensive of words Monday when he rebuked insurers and urged the public to stand up to Congress and fight for passage of a health care overhaul.
By: Kaiser Health News
A Teaspoon Of Sugar to help the Medicine Go Down
A Teaspoon Of Sugar to help the Medicine Go Down
As the power of the placebo, or sugar pill grows, researchers note that it is twice as powerful as it was in the '80's. A little faith in science can go a long way.
By: NPR
Obama and Pelosi on There Own
Obama and Pelosi on There Own
With a vote count not quite high enough, the President and Pelosi are on there own to push for health Reform. "I don't have the votes," Pelosi told the group, according to National Assn. of Public Hospitals and Health Systems President Larry Gage, who was at the meeting.
By: Los Angeles Times
Medicade To Childless Adults
Medicade To Childless Adults
Obama Care to set liability singles, 15M more in the next ten years.
By: Kaiser Health News
Massa: Democrats Ousted Me Over Health Care
Massa: Democrats Ousted Me Over Health Care
"Mine is now the deciding vote on the health care bill," Rep.Massa(D-NY)said. A "No" vote for health care, now under investigation from the Ethics Committee.",they will stop at nothing to pass this health care bill. And now they've gotten rid of me, and it will pass. You connect the dots."
By: Politico
Ignoring Americans, Obama continues his fight
Ignoring Americans, Obama continues his fight
For the first time in American History 'reconciliation' is to be used without the support of both parties or the American public. From the Bush Tax cuts to Welfare reform in '96, the voice of America was loud and clear.
By: Real Clear Politics
Obama's New Adversary
Obama's New Adversary
Sen.Paul Ryan, a key player at Obama's Health Summit last week, broke down the math behind the bill. Ryan correctly stated that the bill projects that Medicare will lower reimbursements to doctors by $371 billion over the next 10 years.
By: The Washington Post
Health Secretary Sebelius Demands Transparency
Health Secretary Sebelius Demands Transparency
After the Wellpoint and Anthem Blue Cross hikes the Secretary of HHS Kathleen Selbelius along with the President meet with the Top Five insures to discuss justification on the rate increase.
By: New York Daily News
Sweeping Processed-Food Recall is Announced
A contaminated batch of an obscure but ubiquitous flavor enhancer sparked recalls of foods ranging from dips to flavored tofu. The Food and Drug Administration said the recalls are a precaution to prevent illness.
By: National Public Radio
Obama Seeks To Mollify Democrats On Health Overhaul Plan, Costs
President Barack Obama intensified his push for health care reform by lobbying small groups of Democratic lawmakers Thursday.
By: Kaiser Health News
Read more YourHealthCareToday